Items

A bundle of letters addressed to the children's families written by the missing children themselves. The letters were written just before the children vanished, indicating they knew they were about to lose their memories and something worse would happen. One notable letter is addressed "To Mother, in case I forget" written in childish handwriting. These letters suggest the children had foreknowledge of the disappearances and the memory curse affecting Bellhollow.

A cloak made of grey rags that belonged to the mysterious pale figure. When Little Timmy pulled it away from the figure in the village square, it fell empty to the cobblestones, revealing that there was no physical form beneath—only empty fabric and shadow. The cloak now lies discarded on the stones of the village square, visible to anyone who looks closely, though most villagers appear to overlook it.